YNAB VS tiller money : Which Debt Payoff App Saves You More Money?

sharing is caring

When you are trying to get rid of debt, you will soon find out that budgeting is not easy. Finding the right tool to manage your money and keep you on track can make a huge difference. 

Two popular options, YNAB (You Need A Budget) and Tiller Money, each offer unique features designed to help you take control of your finances. But which one will actually help you pay off debt faster? In this guide, i will explore the strengths and differences between these two budgeting platforms to help you decide which one fits your financial style and goals best.

Lets get started.

1. You Need A Budget (YNAB)

YNAB is a subscription-based application that adheres to the philosophy of Zero-Based budgeting: assign each dollar an assignment and budget around it. Its core promise? 

So that you can live within your means, pay off debt more quickly, and create a cushion in the future.

Features:

• Category-Based Budgeting – Drag and drop money into categories such as Rent, Debt Payment or Emergency Fund.  
• Goal Tracking – Set specific objectives (e.g., Pay off Student Loan in 24 months) and track progress in real time.  
• Real-Time Sync – Link all your bank accounts and credit cards. Transactions automatically import and classify.  
• Mobile and Web Apps – Interface is the same on phone, tablet or desktop.  
• Educational Resources – An excellent library of articles, videos and annual webinars.  

How You Can Benefit: 

1.No More Hello, I am a debtor Moments – By giving each dollar a purpose, you will be less likely to spend on impulse.  

2.Debt-Payoff Momentum – The YNAB rule of Give Every Dollar a Job challenges you to make debt payments a priority every month.  

3.More Visibility of Cash Flow – You can always know whether you are spending too much in a specific category with real-time updates.  

4.Build Savings Automatically – The money you free up as you pay down debt is deposited in savings categories automatically.  

When you prefer structure, goals, and a guided budgeting process, then you should choose YNAB. 

The learning curve is a steep one, but the community and resources make it worth it. It works particularly well with individuals who wish to not only get out of debt but also begin to build an emergency fund without feeling overwhelmed.

2. Tiller Money

Tiller Money is a spreadsheet-based platform that integrates your financial information into Google Sheets or Excel. 

Consider it a spreadsheet-based budget on steroids, automatically updated, and you have the flexibility of a spreadsheet and the convenience of auto-import.

Features:

• Automated Import – Your bank, credit cards and other accounts will automatically import into a prepared spreadsheet each day.  
• Custom Templates – Select a budgeting, expense tracking, or debt-payoff template. Make your own in case you are a spreadsheet genius.  
• Spreadsheet Flexibility – Create formulas, pivot tables, charts and dashboards to view what you want to see.  
• Mobile Apps – You can still edit Google Sheets or Excel on your phone, but it is more powerful on a bigger screen.  
• No Monthly Subscription – Once you have tried the spreadsheet templates and support, you are charged a one-time fee after the first month.  

How You Can Benefit:

1.Transparency – All transactions are available in a spreadsheet, allowing you to audit, edit or make custom reports.  

2.Complete Flexibility – In case the standardized apps are too restrictive, you can create a debt-payoff system that fits your specific requirements.  

3.Cost-Effective – Once you have paid the subscription fee, you are basically paying to get a collection of well-built templates.  

4.Integrations – Advanced automation is possible with add-ons such as Google Data Studio, Power BI, or Zapier.  

When you are familiar with spreadsheets and prefer to have complete control over the layout and formulas, then Tiller Money is the best choice. It is a little more manual than YNAB, but the auto-sync feature eliminates much of the manual input. Tiller is worth the money to those who are detail oriented and wish to adjust every line item.

3. Comparison Review: Tiller Money vs YNAB.

What’s Good About YNAB:  

• Guided System – In-built philosophy of budgeting that minimizes guesswork.  
• Community & Education – Webins, forums and detailed guides keep the users in check.  
• Automatic Bank Syncing – You do not have to export spreadsheets or enter data manually.  
• Mobile-First Experience – Daytime quick check-ins keep you on schedule.  

What’s Bad About YNAB:

• Monthly Subscription – The monthly price is prohibitive to some, particularly when you are just paying off your debts.  
• Rigid Structure – Less customization of categories or formulas outside the structure of the app.  
• Small Spreadsheet Interface – YNAB may seem constraining to a spreadsheet enthusiast.  

What is Good about Tiller Money?  

• Spreadsheet Power- Complete control, custom formulas, and the possibility to build elaborate dashboards.  
• One-Time Cost – Once you have subscribed, you are basically paying to use a tool which remains free.  
• Very Customizable – You can create dashboards that display the specific metrics that you are interested in (e.g., debt-payoff velocity).  
• Export Friendly Data – All data is in a format that is easy to share or store.  

What’s Bad About Tiller Money:

• Non-Spreadsheet Learning Curve – If you do not feel comfortable with Google Sheets or Excel, it will take time to get set up.  
• Manual Interaction – Although imports are automatic, you still have to edit categories and formulas by hand.  
• Mobile Limitations – It is less convenient to edit on a phone or tablet; the real power is on a desk.  

Which Saves You More Money?  

YNAB is the best at changing behavior. This compels you to allocate each dollar, so you will spend less and achieve your debt-payoff goals faster. Its systematic strategy tends to result in an earlier date of debt freedom.  

Tiller Money excels at data ownership and customization. You can create a spreadsheet layout to highlight your debt-payoff objectives (e.g. a “Debt-Payoff Calendar” which displays monthly progress) and will find it easier to be motivated and see how many dollars are being applied to debt each month.  

The behavioral discipline of YNAB, to most users, will translate into larger savings since it will help you avoid the urge to spend and will make sure that you always pay the highest-interest debt first. 

But when you love to play with formulas and see your money in a spreadsheet, the flexibility of Tiller can make you see exactly how every dollar is spent, which also makes you spend smarter and pay off debt faster.

Final Verdict:  

– When you need a guided, community-based experience that helps you stay on track with the least effort, choose YNAB.  

– Love spreadsheets and would like to have complete control over each line item, select Tiller Money.  

In any case, the most important thing is to save more money by tracking, paying attention to interest rates, and having a habit of zero-based budgeting. 

Choose the tool that seems like a part of your personal character and workflow, and the process of debt-payoff will become less of a burden and more of a meaningful journey toward financial freedom. Happy budgeting!

Whichever app you choose, the most important thing is to take action. A budgeting tool is only as good as the habits you build around it. Choose the one that fits your style and start making smarter financial decisions today!